WV Buy-Sell Agreements

Every closely held business will eventually face an ownership change: an owner dies, becomes disabled, divorces, retires, or simply wants out. A buy-sell agreement decides now, while everyone is healthy and on good terms, who will buy the departing owner’s interest, at what price, and with what money. Holmes Law drafts and reviews buy-sell agreements for West Virginia LLCs, corporations and partnerships, and coordinates them with the owners’ estate plans.

Michael Holmes is admitted in West Virginia and six other states. Holmes Law does not maintain an office in West Virginia; West Virginia clients are served virtually, with consultations, meetings and appearances handled by phone, video and secure document exchange. This page is general information, not legal or tax advice for your company.

Why West Virginia Businesses Need a Buy-Sell Agreement

Without an agreement, West Virginia law fills the gap, and the results are rarely what the owners would have chosen:

  • LLCs. In an at-will LLC, a member who dissociates can generally require the company to buy the interest at fair value (W. Va. Code § 31B-6-603 and § 31B-7-701), with a court setting the value and payment terms if the parties disagree (§ 31B-7-702). That obligation can arrive at the worst possible time and with no funding in place. If an operating agreement fixes the price and terms, those terms govern unless the purchaser defaults (§ 31B-7-701(c)).
  • Corporations. A shareholder has no general right to be bought out. A deceased owner’s family can be left holding illiquid minority shares, while the surviving owners find themselves in business with heirs who never worked in the company.
  • Transfers to outsiders. Without restrictions, an interest can pass by will, intestacy or divorce to someone the other owners did not choose. In an LLC, that person is a transferee with economic rights only (§ 31B-5-503), which preserves control but can create years of conflict over distributions.

A buy-sell agreement can be a standalone contract, part of an LLC operating agreement, or part of a shareholder agreement under W. Va. Code § 31D-7-732. For corporations, W. Va. Code § 31D-6-627 expressly authorizes agreements that obligate a shareholder to first offer shares to the corporation or others, or obligate the corporation or others to buy them.

Triggering Events

Death

Death is the most common trigger and the easiest to fund with life insurance. The agreement usually requires the company or the surviving owners to buy, and the estate to sell, within a fixed period after death or after the personal representative is appointed. It should also address what the estate can do with the interest in the meantime.

Disability

Disability needs a clear definition, such as inability to perform the owner’s normal duties for a set number of months, or a determination under a disability insurance policy. Because disability buyout insurance is less common than life insurance, the agreement often provides for installment payments.

Divorce

West Virginia is an equitable distribution state. A business interest acquired during marriage can be marital property, and the court presumes an equal division (W. Va. Code § 48-7-101 and § 48-7-103). A buy-sell agreement typically gives the company and the other owners an option to buy any interest awarded to the owner’s spouse, and asks each spouse to sign a consent. Owners who want to keep a business separate should also consider a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement; under § 48-1-237, property excluded from marital property by a valid agreement is separate property.

Retirement, resignation and termination

Agreements often distinguish between an owner who retires after a long tenure, one who leaves voluntarily early, and one who is terminated for cause. A common approach pays full value for retirement, a discounted value for an early voluntary departure, and a further discount for cause, though penalty provisions should be drafted carefully.

Other triggers

Bankruptcy, a charging order or creditor levy, loss of a professional license, an attempted transfer in violation of the agreement, and a deadlock between equal owners are frequent additional triggers.

Who Buys: Redemption, Cross-Purchase or Hybrid

  • Entity redemption. The company buys the departing owner’s interest. It is simple to administer, especially with many owners, but distributions to buy out an owner are subject to solvency limits (W. Va. Code § 31B-4-406 for LLCs and § 31D-6-640 for corporations), and redemption funded with company-owned insurance has estate tax consequences discussed below.
  • Cross-purchase. The remaining owners buy the interest directly. The buyers receive a cost basis in the purchased interest, and insurance owned by the individual owners is kept outside the company’s value. With many owners, the number of policies multiplies, which can be handled with a trusteed or partnership arrangement.
  • Hybrid or “wait and see.” The company has the first option to buy, the owners have a second option, and the company must purchase anything not taken. This keeps flexibility until the triggering event occurs.

Valuation Methods

Price is where most buy-sell disputes begin. The main approaches are:

  • Agreed value, updated by the owners each year. It is simple, but owners often forget to update it, so the agreement should provide a fallback if the value is stale.
  • Formula, such as a multiple of earnings or book value. Formulas are predictable but can drift from economic reality.
  • Independent appraisal at the time of the trigger, often with each side selecting an appraiser and a third breaking a tie. This is the most accurate and the most expensive.

The agreement should define the standard of value (fair market value or fair value), state whether minority and marketability discounts apply, set an effective valuation date, and say how life insurance proceeds are treated in the valuation. In an LLC fair-value action, a West Virginia court considers, among other evidence, any agreement among the members fixing the price or a formula (§ 31B-7-702), so a clear valuation clause carries real weight.

Funding the Buyout and Connelly v. United States

Most buy-sell agreements are funded at least in part by life insurance, supplemented by disability insurance, cash reserves, seller financing through a promissory note, or bank financing. Payment terms, interest, security for the note, and acceleration on default should all be spelled out.

In Connelly v. United States, decided June 6, 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held that a corporation’s contractual obligation to redeem a deceased shareholder’s shares is not a liability that reduces the corporation’s value for federal estate tax purposes. Life insurance proceeds the corporation received to fund the redemption were therefore included in the company’s value, increasing the value of the decedent’s shares. The decision affects any redemption-style agreement funded with company-owned life insurance. Owners whose estates may approach the federal exemption should consider whether a cross-purchase structure, an insurance LLC or trust holding the policies, or other changes make sense. The IRS reports the federal basic exclusion amount at $15,000,000 for decedents dying in 2026.

West Virginia Estate Tax Interplay

West Virginia’s estate tax statute, W. Va. Code § 11-11-3, imposes tax only in the amount of the federal credit for state death taxes. Because that federal credit was phased out, West Virginia does not currently collect a separate estate tax. For most West Virginia owners, the tax focus is therefore federal estate tax for large estates and income tax basis planning for everyone. Owners who also hold property in a state with its own estate tax, such as Washington or Massachusetts, need to plan for that state as well. A buy-sell agreement should be reviewed together with the owner’s West Virginia estate plan, including any revocable trust that will hold the business interest.

Restrictive Covenants in a Buy-Sell Agreement

Buyers often want a departing owner to agree not to compete or solicit customers after the buyout. West Virginia courts evaluate such covenants under a rule of reason and are generally more receptive to restrictions given in connection with the sale of a business interest than to restrictions on ordinary employees. A court-ordered LLC buyout may itself include a covenant not to compete as one of the purchase terms (§ 31B-7-702(a)(2)). Physician owners are subject to W. Va. Code § 47-11E-2, which limits noncompetes in physician employment contracts to one year and 30 road miles. For a fuller discussion, see WV Business Contracts.

Structuring and Maintaining the Agreement

  • Sign the agreement early, when owners have equal uncertainty about who will leave first.
  • Have all owners and their spouses sign, and legend share certificates or membership records with the transfer restrictions (§ 31D-6-627 requires a conspicuous notation for corporations).
  • Confirm that the insurance owners, beneficiaries and amounts match the agreement.
  • Revisit the price at least annually, and review the entire agreement after any change in owners, a large loan, or a change in tax law.
  • Coordinate the agreement with the operating or shareholder agreement so the documents do not conflict (see WV Operating & Shareholder Agreements).

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a buy-sell agreement required in West Virginia?

No, but without one, an LLC may face a mandatory fair-value buyout at a member’s request, and a corporation’s shareholders may have no exit at all. An agreement replaces those uncertain outcomes with agreed terms.

Should we use a cross-purchase or an entity redemption?

It depends on the number of owners, the tax basis consequences, solvency, and the Connelly estate tax issue for redemption agreements funded with company-owned insurance. Many companies now choose a cross-purchase or hybrid design.

Is the buy-sell price binding in a West Virginia divorce?

A buy-sell price is not automatically binding on a family court valuing marital property, but the agreement’s restrictions and purchase option can control who ends up owning the interest. A marital agreement offers stronger protection.

Does West Virginia have an estate tax that affects our buyout?

West Virginia does not currently collect a separate estate tax because its statute is tied to a federal credit that was phased out. Federal estate tax can still apply to larger estates.

Can the agreement include a noncompete?

Yes, if it is reasonable in duration, geography and scope and protects a legitimate business interest. Physician noncompetes are subject to specific statutory limits.

Do our spouses have to sign?

A spousal consent is not legally required to create the agreement, but it is strongly recommended because a spouse may claim a marital interest in the business in a divorce or as an heir.

Speak With a West Virginia Buy-Sell Agreement Attorney

A buy-sell agreement is one of the most valuable documents a closely held business can sign, and it works best when drafted alongside the owners’ estate plans. Holmes Law prepares new West Virginia buy-sell agreements and reviews existing ones, including redemption agreements that may need attention after Connelly. Call (681) 661-0448. Holmes Law does not maintain an office in West Virginia; West Virginia clients are served virtually, with consultations, meetings and appearances handled by phone, video and secure document exchange. Visit the West Virginia business law page, read about WV entity formation, or contact Holmes Law to schedule a consultation.

This page provides general information about West Virginia law and is not legal advice. Reading it, or contacting Holmes Law, does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, fees and filing requirements change, so confirm current rules before acting.